To give you some background info, about two years ago I switched from Windows to Ubuntu and never looked back.
At the start of this year, I enrolled in a Media Arts course, included in the tuition fees is a MacBook. I received it about a week and a half ago and have been using it ever since.
Here are some of my observations and impressions so far.
Appearance:
Shiny, polished and elegant. I am using default themes and styles, yet I am impressed by the quality of artwork. The entire operating system has a very nice polished look and feel to it. One can tell that a lot of thought has gone into the layout and design.
Ubuntu, despite being much easier to customise than OS X, is a step behind in terms of default theme layout and design. It lacks some of the polish. Of course this is also a matter of opinion, beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
Quitting Applications:
For the first couple of days I had a hard time getting used to the fact that, in order to quit an application, you must navigate to the application menu and select quit from there. Clicking on the ‘x’ in a window will not do it.
I am still not quite sure what the reasoning is behind this, and I do feel that in stark contrast to many other usability aspects, this is counter-intuitive, but I have gotten used to it now.
Integration:
This is something I really admire in OS X Leopard. Everything is tied together; settings, configurations and options. It saves time and avoids redundancy.
Application Diversity
Here Ubuntu wins hands down. To be fair, the package of applications that is included in each of these operating systems is affected by the nature of the usage licence.
Ubuntu is free and open source, as such it includes, from the start, just about all applications you might need; office suite, multi-protocol messenger, good dvd/cd burning applications, good image manipulation applications, various multi-codec video and audio applications.
OS X Leopard on the other hand, being a proprietary product, comes with basic applications. Given the nature of Apple, they of course want you to buy their more enhanced applications such as office suites etc.., hence one needs to hunt down and install various applications, such as Adium or NeoOffice to be truly productive.
Stability:
So far OS X has been very stable. I have not experienced any system crashes. I did experience the Mail application quitting unexpectedly while I was trying to import my emails from Evolution, I was however able to circumvent this annoyance by breaking my emails into 3-4 smaller packages.
I am also a little annoyed by the display errors that I noticed while using Adobe Flash. I am not sure if this is due to Flash or OS X. Sometimes menus will not update until you move your mouse over them. This comes as somewhat of a surprise for a product that caters to designers and artists.
Hardware Design:
The design of the MacBook is very impressive. The features I like most are the MagSafe power connector, which is magnetic, and therefore attaches to the power plug by itself once brought close. The status leds on the battery which light up to inform you how much juice is left in your battery without the need to have the laptop running (i.e. you do not need to launch your operating system to see the battery status).
Conclusion:
Overall the MacBook and OS X Leopard have been a pleasant surprise. Windows had greatly damaged my opinion of proprietary software and operating systems. Apple has improved this image, although as far as I am concerned, free and open source software, while perhaps not looking sexiest, will always be one step ahead in terms of flexibility, development speed and security.
I am looking forward to see how well the upcoming Ubuntu release will fair on the MacBook, stay tuned for a report on that.